Michael Gove: The Lefts hatred of Israel is Antisemitism in disguise. Critics of the Jewish State cannot bear the fact that it is a beacon of western values in a sea of tyranny and despotism.

Michael Andrew Gove is a British Conservative politician, who was Secretary of State for Education from 2010 to 2014 and Secretary of State for Justice from 2015-2016. He has been the member of parliament for Surrey Heath since 2005. God bless him! How do you know if someone’s  an anti-Semite.They don`t all perform stiff arm salutes for the camera and offer 140-character thoughts about race theory on Twitter. Although those are helpful clues, as the American alt-right, Hezbollah and Iran`s leadership prove.

But anti-Semitism isn’t a prejudice restricted to the likes of Richard Spencer, Hassan Nasrallah and Ayatollah Ali Khamenei. As befits the worlds oldest and most durable hatred, it has many more adherents and has taken many different forms.

In medieval times, when individuals made sense of their world through the prism of faith, anti-Semitism was a religious prejudice. In the 19th and early 20th century–the age  of Darwinism- anti-Semitism clothed itself in the white coat of the scientist. Biological metaphors were deployed to modernize hate. The Jews were carriers of “racial contamination” who had to be eliminated as a pathological threat to humanity`s future.

That belief led to history`s greatest crime. The extermination of six million powered by hatred of one thing–Jewish identity. It should have been the case that anti-Semitism died  in the furnaces of the holocaust. But the hatred survived. And like a virus, mutated.

Anti-Semitism has moved from hatred of Jews on religious or racial grounds to hostility towards the proudest expression of Jewish identity we now have–the Jewish State.

No other democracy is on the receiving end of a campaign calling for its people to be shunned and their labour to be blacklisted.  The Boycott, Disinvestment and Sanctions movement is a growing force on our streets and campuses.  Its campaigners argue that we should ignore ideas from Jewish thinkers if those thinkers come from Israel and treat Jewish commerce as a criminal enterprise if that business is carried on in Israel.

This is anti-Semitism, impure and simple.  It is the latest recrudescence of the age-old demand that the Jew can only live on terms set by others.  Once Jews had to live in the ghetto, now they cannot live in their historic home.

It is to this country’s eternal credit that we rejected centuries of prejudice one hundred years ago and pledged to extend to the Jewish people the rights enjoyed by Germans and Italians, Japanese and Mexicans — the right to a land they could call their own.  The Balfour Declaration in 1917 was followed in 1948 with the creation of the state of Israel.  Since then, that state’s success has been near miraculous.

No other democracy is on the receiving end of a campaign calling for its people to be shunned and their labour to be blacklisted.

Surrounded by enemies who sought to strangle it at birth, continually threatened by war and constantly under terrorist attack, a nation scarcely the size of Wales with no natural resources, half of whose territory is desert, has become a flourishing democracy, a centre of scientific innovation, one of the world’s major providers of international humanitarian relief and the only state from Casablanca to Kabul with a free press, free judiciary, a flourishing free enterprise economy and freedom for people of every sexual orientation to live and love as they wish.

And that is the reason it attracts such hostility.  Not because of what Israel does.  But because of what it is.

For those on the left addicted to guilt-tripping and grievance-mongering, who believe that poverty is a consequence of western exploitation and that bourgeois ethics lead to oppression, the existence of a political entity that is a runaway success precisely because it is a bourgeois-minded, capitalist-fuelled, western-oriented nation state is just too much to bear.  Their ideological prejudices have collided with a stubborn, undeniable fact.

So what do they do?  Keep the prejudices, of course, and try to get rid of the fact.  Try to undermine, delegitimise and reduce support for Israel.  Make it the only country in the world whose right to exist is called continually into question.  Make the belief in that state’s survival, Zionism, a dirty word.  Denounce, as the NUS president has, a British university for being a “Zionist outpost”.  And instead call organizations pledged to eliminate Israel such as Hezbollah and Hamas “friends”, as Jeremy Corbyn has.

Antizionism is not a brave anti-colonial and anti-racist stance, it is simply anti-Semitism minding its manners so it can sit in a seminar room.  And as such it deserves to be called out, confronted and opposed.

Because the fate of the Jewish people, and the survival of the Jewish state are critical tests for all of us.  The darkest forces of our time –Islamic State, the Iranian leaders masterminding mass murder in Aleppo — are united by one thing above all: their hatred of the Jewish people and their home.  Faced with such implacable hatred, and knowing where it has always led, we should not allow anti-Semitism any space to advance, or incubate.

Instead we should show we’re not going to be intimidated by those who want to treat Israel as a second-class state, we’re not going to indulge the anti-Semitic impulse to apply the double standard.  Israel is the only state where we don’t locate our embassy in the nation’s capital and the only ally the Foreign Office has refused to let the Queen visit.  So let’s celebrate the centenary of the Balfour Declaration by moving our embassy to Jerusalem next year and inviting Her Majesty to open it.  What are we afraid of?  Earning the enmity of those who hate Israel?  To my mind thee could be no greater compliment.

An addition by Murray Rubin

In 1948 when I was 17 years old I supported Israel because I was Jewish and it had been granted status by the United Nations. I also felt why should all nations have their own country and not Israel. No more! I now support the existence of the State of Israel for selfish  and personal reasons. When so much of Europe, the home of the holocaust can be so anti-Semitic, and the U.S. can elect a president like Barack Obama, the Jews need a country that will always accept them no matter what happens.






Name of author

Name: Murray Rubin

Short Bio: I was born in Toronto in 1931 to a wonderful mother who divorced shortly before my birth. I owe a great deal of my success to her. I am Jewish but not at all religious, yet my culture plays an important part of my personality. I attended Harbord Collegiate and U. of T. Faculty of Pharmacy. A unique mail-order pharmacy was the first of my endeavours in the profession, followed by many stores throughout Ontario. I have a loving wife, 3 children and grand-children and I am now retired from pharmacy. But what do I write about? Everything! My topics are funny, serious, whimsical, timely, outrageous, inspiring, and inventive. I promise that if you take the time to read any one of these topics – you will not be sorry.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *